Thursday, August 30, 2012

WHICH DO YOU PREFER?

I got an email from my younger sister yesterday asking for help in choosing a nightstand for her master bedroom.
I thought I'd ask you, my design- savvy readers, for your opinion.


Choice #1


or 

Choice #2


and to help you decide, here's a picture of the room...
(it is going to replace the white nightstand)

Both are good.
I have my preference though.  Can you guess which one?

Which one do you like better?


23 comments:

Melissa Crochet @ The Insane Domain said...

Choice 2! Love the detail.

Jessie said...

Hands down, the first one! The first nightstand is gorgeous and less busy compared to the second one. The second one is lovely but I will pair it with a bed in a solid color. I think the first option will contrast beautifully with the patterned headboard.

Jessie
www.mixandchic.com

Anonymous said...

the second one, love it!

Mrs. Chic said...

I love option # 2 :)

Bethany [at] Powell Brower Home said...

OOOOOOOH choice 2! the other one feel so distinctly 80s crossed with art deco that i dont feel it would last as long, when tastes change. i think the second one has a wonderful patina and great detail on it, and would look great with the busy headboard. Of course, it's all IMHO, but, was fun to weigh in!

Vel Criste said...

#2, #2!!! So unique and pretty! I like the first one too, but not as much as no. 2. I think your leaning towards no. 2 too!:-)

Kat said...

#2 gets my vote! Love all the details!

Anonymous said...

I agree with Jessie - I think #2 is great on its own, but #1 fits the spot better given the already busy headboard.

LiveLaughDecorate said...

Definitely #1 lady. They are both fab, but the second one is chock full of details that will go in a head-to-head battle with the headboard's busy fabric. Just my two cents worth.

Anonymous said...

#2 looks much more expensive

Erin said...

Tough! I think I like #2 bc it's diff than what you normally see in mirrored furniture and I like the detail.

Anonymous said...

# 2-looks a little bit larger-think the space could use that.

Tiffany Leigh Interior Design said...

I love them both, but I think the cleaner look of dresser number 1 will go better with the busy headboard fabric (as some have already mentioned). The scale of number 2 might be better though...and now, after all that I just can't decide!

Hannah said...

Choice 2 by far. For the win!!! I just posted about black drapes in my bedroom... would love to hear your thoughts!

christinaw said...

Definitely choice #2 !! Good luck

Beth of designPOST Interiors said...

#2 gives off the vibe that it has some history and character...definitely my pick!

pam {simple details} said...

I can't decide if I think #2 competes with or compliments the headboard. I love the unique details on it. I'd bring both of them home and test them if I were undecided.

Anonymous said...

Guess I'm an outlier but I think definitely #1. I feel like #2 has one trend too many- either nailhead OR antiqued mirror, but not both. #1 is a claasic; I never like my furniture to be id'd by when a trend hit.

AWalker said...

#2

Anonymous said...

#1, it's less busy, although I would have picked the 2nd one if it weren't for the headboard that is already in place. I love the unique look of the 2nd one.

My Crafty Home Life said...

Haha...looks like it is close to a tie. I say 1

lemondropdreams said...

#2...it's more unique

Julia {Pawleys Island Posh} said...

NO. 2!!! NO QUESTION!!! It's got so much more character and potential. It could be used in so many different rooms and different styles. It looks so much more expensive and unique too.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails